David Guetta, who is 52, explained during an interview with Mcfly et Carlito on Sunday that he was approached by Madonna (now 62) in 2011, after he won a Grammy for Best Remixed Recording, after remixing her 2009 song “Revolver.” He says she informed him that she loved the remix so much that she wanted him to produce her next album. Going off that timeline, she would have been talking about what would go on to be her 12th studio album, 2012’s MDNA. David was also a huge producer at the time. So of course Madonna was excited. That is, until they got to the inevitable small talk question about David’s sign.